Yeah, Sage is hot, I don't disagree. But in a game of FMK, it would be Sage/Josy/Maya for me. I'll even throw in an Ignore for Jill & Avoid for Bella to complete the primary LI set. Feel free to disagree.
For me it would probably be this:
F: Bella - A huge fantasy of many college-aged boys: A good looking teacher and librarian. I wouldn't want anything longterm as long as she's still officially married however, just to avoid complications.
M: Sage: The perfect combination of brains, beauty, good personality and redhead to top it all off. It cannot get much better.
K: Maya: Almost fanatic religious father, a lesbian in a bicurious phase and too trusting about her father, even when she already know he was against her being a lesbian. No thanks.
I: Jill: I like Jill as a character, but avoid her like the plague on a relationship level. She herself has massive trust issues and I don't think that her family will be all to pleased with her having a relationship with a nobody.
A: Josy: To me it looks like she's either going to become an equivalent to "overly attached girlfriend" if you're in a relationship or a massive stalker in the making if you're not. Avoid like the plague just to be safe.